Faith, Law, and Leadership: The Multi-Faceted Career of Karla Fiaoni

By Rachel Barks

Karla Fiaoni possesses the ability to see the justice system from every possible angle. From the high-stakes environment of the State’s Attorney’s Office to her tenure as a Chief of Police, she has been a pillar of strength and a voice for the vulnerable. Her career is not merely a collection of titles, but a testament to a life dedicated to integrity and the pursuit of “doing the right thing.”

In 1994, Fiaoni became a trailblazer as the first female Chief of Police in Cook County, one of only four in the entire state at the time.

“I hired two female officers as soon as possible and mentored them throughout my tenure,” Fiaoni recalls, noting with pride that those bonds remain today. This spirit of mentorship and advocacy has been a hallmark of her journey, extending from the police department to her long-standing work with domestic violence agencies and local pro bono legal assistance clinics.

“Having been on all sides of the Criminal Justice System, and having practiced law since 1989, I come to these cases with a realistic and practical perspective,” Fiaoni shares. After her contractual commitment in Chicago Heights, she chose to return to private practice to maintain her independence, focusing on criminal defense and aiding low-income women and children. Her practice became a place for those seeking a lawyer who understood the complexity of the law from the inside out.

While the legal landscape has shifted toward a digital-first era, Fiaoni remains “old school” at heart. Though she appreciates the efficiency of a Zoom call for convenient matters, she believes the core of the profession lies in human connection. “I always choose to appear in court in person,” she notes. “It helps the attorney-client relationship and betters the communication.”

Outside of the courtroom, Fiaoni’s legacy extends beyond her work as an attorney. Fiaoni is an author of two published books: An Illustration of Grace and Time, Talent and Treasure. A third book, Stop Chasing the Devil’s Shiny Object, is currently in the writing stage. Both books are self-published and are given away as part of her women’s ministry. Through her women’s ministry, Fiaoni connects with other women, particularly young women and teenage girls, to share her story and give them confidence, courage and hope.

Fiaoni views women’s ministry as a calling and vocation, and also views her career the same way, more than just a job. “My faith is something I carry with me 24/7,” she explains. “I like to believe we are all given the opportunity to serve in our vocations and community, and it’s just a matter of stopping the busy ‘rat race’ and taking the time to see the opportunity.”

“There is no doubt that Karla has saved the lives of many people as a Prosecutor, Chief of Police, Defense attorney and forerunner of advocating for victims of domestic abuse,” states Richard Albanese.

Her advice to the next generation of lawyers is as grounded as her practice: enter the field only if it is your passion and guard your reputation fiercely: “Always tell the truth, maintain your dignity and integrity and whenever possible—HAVE FUN!”

Fiaoni remains a “glass half-full” optimist, finding gratitude in everything from a major court victory to a great parking spot. Her wise and compassionate touch continues to leave a lasting print on the legal community and the lives of those she serves.